Farah Belhaj, Manager HR Services, Polyglot Group
Most managers have had that sinking feeling when they realise a new hire isn’t quite what they expected. In my experience, the issue often starts much earlier than the performance review.
Before someone joins your business, ask yourself: “What does success actually look like in 90 days?”
If you can’t answer that clearly, performance becomes subjective. Managers rely on gut feel, employees are left trying to work out what’s expected of them, and conversations about performance become harder than they need to be.
That’s why I encourage managers to set clear outcomes before day one and revisit them at 30, 60 and 90 days. Those conversations shouldn’t be based on whether someone feels like a good fit. They should focus on what’s been achieved, where support may be needed, and whether expectations are being met.
Perhaps the most important thing to remember is that performance reviews should be a two-way conversation. While employees are accountable for their performance, managers are equally accountable for creating the conditions for success. Were expectations clear? Was feedback provided early enough? Did the employee have the support they needed?
And that shouldn’t stop once probation ends. Regular quarterly check-ins help keep performance on track and reduce surprises for both sides. Don’t use reviews to build a case after the fact. Use them to spot issues while you can still do something about them.
Tiffany English, Founder and Managing Director, Access Offshoring
A good performance review starts before you even hire someone. You need to define what success looks like at 30, 60 and 90 days, then review against those outcomes rather than how busy your employee appears to be. A simple scorecard built around the role’s core skills, agreed milestones, and expected behaviours keeps the conversation clear, can reduce subjectivity, and helps you manage your team proactively.
If something feels off at the 30-day mark, talk about it then and don’t wait for three months to pass until you do a review. Put your feedback in writing so both sides know what needs to change and can track the progress at the next check-in.
Probation gives you a useful window to do this, particularly with a formal midpoint review before the six-month mark. Also, if you only measure technical performance, you miss out on understanding how someone communicates and responds to feedback to improve how they work with the broader team.
Skills can often be developed with the right support, but behaviours and values matter just as much when you’re deciding whether someone is the right long-term fit.